Rodrigo Duterte ICC case update |
ICC evidence disclosure and the use of AI-generated evidence summaries |

For Quezon City residents following the Rodrigo Duterte ICC case, the latest dispute turns on a question: who must make sense of thousands of evidence files?
Duterte’s lawyers argue that prosecutors cannot hand over a spreadsheet of AI-generated evidence summaries and leave the defense to determine what matters.
The disagreement over ICC evidence disclosure is more than a technical fight about document management.
It could affect how thoroughly both sides examine material tied to allegations arising from the anti-drug campaign.
In a request made public October 9, the defense asked Trial Chamber III for permission to respond to prosecutors’ account of the disputed dataset.
The defense says the spreadsheet covers 44,495 of 62,034 disclosed items, while a smaller portion also appears on the prosecution’s evidence list.
Its concern is that summaries generated by software may make an incomplete collection look like a reliable account of deaths linked to police operations.
Prosecutors, in an earlier filing, maintained that they had disclosed material they considered incriminating and identified items directly relevant to the charged incidents.
Duterte’s lawyers dispute whether the wider dataset received the human review needed to distinguish incriminating, exonerating and otherwise relevant material.
They also argue that sorting those files should not become the defense team’s responsibility simply because the volume is daunting.
That distinction matters: a searchable spreadsheet may help someone find a document, but it does not settle whether the document has been properly assessed.
The defense says an earlier offer of access to analysis software was withdrawn, with a more conventional document platform and spreadsheet proposed instead.
During a September hearing, defense counsel said the team had explored its own AI option but considered the potential cost substantial.
For people in Quezon City still living with the campaign’s consequences, confidence in the process depends on careful scrutiny, not just faster searches.
The chamber has not yet ruled on the latest defense request.
A further status conference is scheduled for October 13, when the handling of evidence may remain a central point of contention. |

0 Comments
Join the conversation
Be the first to comment
Share your thoughts above.